caregivers asked, experts answered

Caregivers Asked, the Experts Answered: Finding Peace in the Chaos

If the "Sister" sketch from Saturday Night Live hit a little too close to home this week, you're not alone. The parody of brothers outsourcing their parents' care to their sisters went viral because so many people, most often daughters, recognized themselves in it. Behind the laughs is something real: the appointments, the medications, the late-night worry, and the guilt of never feeling like you've done enough.

Just days before the sketch aired, more than 1,500 caregivers registered for our free webinar, Peace During the Chaos, and asked our experts the questions they carry every day. Here's what they asked, and what Tana Amen, Barbara Gustavson, and Lisa Anders answered.

Doing it all while your siblings watch from the sidelines? Jump to: How do I deal with a sibling whose “help” only makes more work for me? · How can we unify as siblings and share the responsibility?

If you're caring for a parent, a spouse, a child, or a loved one through illness, dementia, or decline, you already know a truth that's hard to say out loud: caregiving can quietly take everything you have. In a recent Amen University webinar, Peace During the Chaos, caregivers from across the country shared their most honest, aching questions—and two people who have lived this journey answered them with remarkable candor.

Tana Amen, BSN, RN—a former neurosurgical ICU trauma nurse, New York Times bestselling author, and caregiver to both her mother and father—spoke openly about how hard it really is. Alongside her, Barbara Gustavson, a brain health coach and trainer at Amen University who navigated a 15-year caregiving journey with her own father, offered practical, brain-based tools. Their graduate and mentor Lisa Anders, who cared for a brother with frontotemporal dementia and now a father with Alzheimer's, added her own hard-won wisdom.

What follows are the top questions caregivers asked, and the team's answers—gathered here so you can return to them whenever you need them. If you're a caregiver, please hear this first: what you're feeling is not weakness. It's human. And your own well-being is the foundation everything else depends on.

"How do I handle the guilt?"

Guilt was the feeling that came up most. As Tana put it, caregivers find guilt no matter what they do: "If you're not spending enough time with that person because you're busy doing other stuff, if you're spending too much time with them and you're not doing this other stuff… we find reasons to beat ourselves up." Was I a good enough daughter? Could I have done more?

Her antidote is a simple thought exercise she and Dr. Amen use constantly—a set of questions drawn from Byron Katie's work, thework.com, and taught in depth in Amen University's OVERCOME course. When a guilty thought hits, write it down and ask:

  1. Is it true?
  2. Can I know that it's absolutely true?
  3. How do I feel when I believe that thought?
  4. Who would I be without that thought?

Then flip it to its opposite and ask whether the reverse might be just as true, or truer. Take the thought "I didn't do enough"—and then honestly list everything you actually did. "You just start to crack the thought," Tana said. "You have to have a way to manage those negative thoughts, and be honest with yourself, because they're usually not true."

This is exactly the kind of work the brain responds to. Dr. Amen calls these distorted inner messages automatic negative thoughts, or ANTs, and learning to answer them is a genuine, trainable skill. Barbara added a tender observation: for many caregivers, underneath "I'm not doing enough" sits a deeper, harder belief—"I'm not enough." Naming that is often where the healing starts.

"Isn't setting boundaries selfish—or disrespectful to my family?"

Tana noticed that few words trigger caregivers like boundaries. "People have this idea, especially when I relate it to parents or family, that the word boundary means dishonor, disrespect, not loving, or lacking gratitude. That is not what the word boundary means."

Her reframe is worth memorizing: boundaries and love are not mutually exclusive. "I can honor my mother and acknowledge that I need to sleep, so maybe I need to have someone help me." You can love someone with your whole heart, respect them, and still protect your own needs. In fact, boundaries are what make it possible to keep going at all. As the team said more than once: you cannot take care of someone else if you are not taking care of yourself—you will get sick.

A few of Tana's practical notes:

  • Practice boundaries before you're in crisis. "Look in the mirror and start practicing." It's much harder to learn them in the middle of grief.
  • Learn to say yes to help. "It's so hard for us to say yes when people offer help. You've got to learn to say yes."
  • Recognize where the guilt comes from. Sometimes it's rooted in cultural or family dynamics—and naming that loosens its grip.

"My body is screaming at me to stop—and I can't. What do I do?"

This question came straight from the chat, and it may be the most important one of all. Tana shared that while caring for her dying father, she—a nurse who rarely got headaches—suddenly started getting migraines. A hospice nurse stopped her and said: You're a trauma nurse, used to doing. You're not grieving outwardly, so it's going to come out in your body. As Tana put it, "The body keeps the score."

If your body is sending distress signals—migraines, rashes, getting sick, exhaustion—please treat that as information to act on, not push through. Protecting your rest and sleep matters enormously; chronic sleep loss worsens mood, patience, and pain, as the research on sleep and the stress cycle shows. And please see your own doctor about physical symptoms.

Barbara's answer centered on one word: support. "To try to carry that yourself is very heavy. I would encourage anyone, even just to have that one person to help lighten that load." Her guidance:

  • Ask for help, even when you don't know exactly what to ask for. "Start with where you are."
  • The first person may not have the answer—but they may have a resource. One connection leads to another.
  • Reach out to someone who's been through a caregiving journey. Their perspective is gold.

If you don't have family or friends nearby, help still exists. Free resources like the Eldercare Locator (1-800-677-1116) and the Family Caregiver Alliance can connect you to respite, support groups, and services, many of them low- or no-cost.

"I feel immobilized. I know what to do, but there's just too much going on."

Several caregivers described feeling frozen. Barbara named the brain science behind it: "When I'm feeling immobilized, I'm literally not feeling safe. My brain is interpreting that I'm in danger, and I go through this freeze moment."

Two tools help melt that freeze:

  • Write it down. "It starts to immediately calm that amygdala part of your brain." Naming a feeling quiets the brain's emotional alarm center—the same overactive-alarm pattern seen in an anxious brain.
  • Shrink the next step until it's tiny. When her dad had a fall, Barbara would give herself permission to take a deep breath, then ask, "What's the one next thing I need to do?"—not the whole problem, just the next small piece.

"Sometimes when we're in that state, we see the whole problem," she said. "How can we take one piece of that and focus on that?"

“How do I deal with a sibling whose ‘help’ only makes more work for me?”

Family dynamics were a recurring source of pain. For the caregiver whose sibling's help created more headaches, Barbara offered a vivid mental tool a nurse once gave her: picture a pie with eight slices. Each slice represents one thing—your dad, a decision you have to make, a sibling you have to work with.

"Before you go into a situation, think about which slice of the pie you need to focus on, and which slice you need to set aside for now, knowing you'll revisit it." That simple act of compartmentalizing, she said, "really helped my brain focus on the one task at hand."

“How can we unify as siblings and share the responsibility?”

For families trying to pull together, Barbara recommended a structured family meeting—but with a crucial first step. Before diving into logistics, "go around the room and get a pulse on what everyone's expectations are, and what matters to them."

Why start there? "Often, by listening to each family member, you can really get a sense of what's weighing on them." From that understanding, you can clarify and share roles—remembering that a nearby family member's role looks very different from a long-distance one. The key, she said, is "really listening to what the person's saying, because with all those emotions, we get into the heat of the discussions versus listening to what is weighing on people." A conversation like that can draw a family closer—or reveal what needs to shift.

"How do I stop feeling resentful as a full-time, live-in caregiver?"

Barbara first honored the courage it takes to admit this: "A lot of people don't admit that, so thank you for that question." Then she offered a path. "Sometimes inner peace is making peace with yourself first," she said—starting with grace, even when resentful ANTs are firing.

She walked the resentment through the same questions Tana shared: Is this thought true? Is it 100% true? How do I show up when I feel resentful? How would I show up if I didn't have those resentful thoughts? Then land on a turnaround statement—an affirmation or, for those with strong faith, a scripture—such as, "I will give myself more grace today."

"How do I cope with grief—especially when it's messy, or it's grief for a future I won't get?"

Tana was strikingly honest that grief is rarely clean. After her mother passed, cleaning out her home surfaced old, painful memories from a difficult childhood she thought she'd already worked through. "I wanted clean grief," she said. "This wasn't clean grief for me. This was messy." Her insight: "You're going to have a relationship with grief. You either have a good relationship with it or a bad one—but it's there, and there's no way around it."

She also named forms of grief that often go unseen:

  • Anticipatory grief—mourning someone while they're still alive.
  • Emotional caregiving from a distance, which still carries real grief.
  • Grieving a future you won't get, like a parent of a child with special needs grieving "the wedding, the graduations, the grandbabies." One caregiver described it as feeling "punished and imprisoned for a crime I didn't commit"—an honest, human assessment.

To process her own messy grief, Tana did something concrete: EMDR therapy.

"What is EMDR, and does it have to be done in therapy?"

Tana was quick to say she's not a therapist, but she described EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing) as "the greatest gift I gave myself." It took only about five sessions. "Those memories don't go away—their power over you goes away."

In her words, it's a trauma-informed therapy for when trauma "gets stuck in the emotional centers of your brain. You're not hypnotized, you're not brainwashed—what it does is help you process it," and, with a skilled therapist, replace those feelings with something more empowering. "When it's stuck, your emotional centers are just lit up, and you spin on it. This helps you release it."

Important: EMDR should be done with a trained, licensed therapist. You can find one through the EMDR International Association, emdria.org.

"How do you find peace on the hardest days?"

Finally, the question underneath all the others. For Tana, peace came from faith and from family and community. But she also shared a daily discipline that helped her carry overwhelming sadness: redirecting her thoughts. When grief would crash over her, she'd pause, pray, and ask what her mother would actually want. "She would want to know that we're thriving." Then she'd deliberately replace the heavy thoughts with funny memories of her larger-than-life mom. "It didn't happen immediately, but it really started to happen. It was discipline."

Barbara built a simple grounding practice around this same idea—anchoring to the present moment. Instead of scanning your whole overwhelming situation, ask: Do I have everything I need in this moment? Am I breathing? Am I safe? Do I have a few minutes to myself? "When our brain in this season is scanning for threats, focusing on the moment retrains it that there's still good happening, even while all this is happening." Because of neuroplasticity, these small redirections genuinely reshape the brain over time—the hopeful truth at the heart of Dr. Amen's work that you are not stuck with the brain you have.

Lisa Anders put it most simply. Each morning, she and her mother make a choice: "We're gonna have a good day." They don't know what the path holds, so they take tiny steps, lean on faith, and trust that "we have the light for one step at a time. Tomorrow, we don't know what's gonna happen, but we're gonna love him today."

For the Brothers (and Anyone Who Wants to Help)

If you're the sibling who isn't doing the day-to-day caregiving, here's the most helpful thing you can do: don't ask "What can I do to help?" That still leaves your sister to figure out and assign every task. Instead, pick something specific and own it—like handling the insurance calls, covering one weekend a month, managing the pharmacy refills, or simply calling her to ask how she's doing. As Tana shared, you can't take care of someone else if you're not taking care of yourself, and sometimes the best care for a caregiver is taking one thing off her plate for good.

A Gentle Reminder: Caring for You Is Caring for Them

If there's one message the team wanted every caregiver to leave with, it's this, in Barbara's words: "You don't need to overhaul your life this week. Think about the tiniest step you can take for yourself… Caring for yourself is also caring for the ones you love, because most likely they are worried about you—they just don't communicate it."

You spend so much of yourself caring for someone else. You deserve care, too.

Watch the full Peace During the Chaos webinar replay, and download the free Finding Peace in Chaos exercise.

Find Real Support for the Weight You're Carrying

Many of the tools in this webinar—including the thought-questioning exercise and the "Finding Peace in the Chaos" practice Barbara led—come directly from Amen University's OVERCOME: Anxiety, Depression, Trauma, and Grief course, developed by Dr. Daniel Amen and Tana Amen. It's a flexible, self-paced program built around exactly what caregivers need: practical, brain-based tools to calm anxiety, process grief, quiet negative thinking, and find steadier ground—one tiny step at a time.

If the guilt, resentment, grief, or exhaustion in these questions sounds like your life right now, this course was made for this season. Explore OVERCOME today and take one small step toward feeling more like yourself again.

And if you ever feel you simply cannot go on, please reach out right away—in the U.S. you can call or text 988 anytime to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. Asking for help is one of the bravest, most brain-healthy things you can do. For ongoing encouragement, caregiver and Amen University mentor Lisa Anders also shares stories of resilience and faith on her podcast, Dust to Grace (listen on Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube).

Related Posts

Why "Just Think Positive" Fails (and What Actually Rewires the Brain)

 You know the advice. You're overwhelmed, anxious, or stuck in a spiral of worry, and someone offers the well-meaning fix: "Just think positive!" Maybe...
Post by Lorenzo Sevilla
Nov 15 2026

9 Everyday Brain Drainers Hiding in Your Routine

You don't need a major health crisis to feel like your brain isn't firing on all cylinders. For most people, the slow drain is...
Post by Mitchell Adams
Nov 12 2026

5 Signs Someone's Anxiety Is Really a Brain Health Issue

Anxiety is one of the most common reasons people seek help. For many, it responds well to familiar approaches—therapy, lifestyle changes, and sometimes medication....
Post by Lorenzo Sevilla
Nov 09 2026

The Purpose Problem: Why "What's It All For?" Is a Brain Health Question

It usually shows up in the quiet moments. Lying awake at 3 a.m. Driving home from a job that pays the bills but stirs...
Post by Mitchell Adams
Nov 06 2026

How Elite Clinical Mentors Are Transforming Patient Care – Join the Brain Health Revolution

Clinicians today are on the frontlines of a mental health crisis, and they urgently need new tools to meet the rising demand for care....
Post by Mitchell Adams
Nov 03 2026

Why Your Brain Loves to Be Scared (The Neuroscience of a Good Fright)

Your heart is pounding. Your palms are sweaty. Something just lunged out of the shadows, and for a split second you were absolutely certain...
Post by Mitchell Adams
Oct 31 2026

Small Daily Habits That Quietly Transform Your Brain

We tend to believe that changing our lives requires something dramatic. A total overhaul. A fresh start on Monday. A bold resolution powered by...
Post by Lorenzo Sevilla
Oct 28 2026